It ain't nothing like that first five
It ain't nothing like that first time
We got sick of playing both sides
We got sick of playing
Cause we didn't know if it was right
We didn't know if it was the right time
We just got sick of feeling alone
The feeling of happiness wasn't known
What we came to every night wasn't a home
We felt like we was loving all along
And we started to blame it on ourselves
Until we found we needed someone else
It ain't nothing like that first five
It ain't nothing like that first time
We got sick of playing both sides
We got sick of playing
We got sick of playing

It ain't nothing like that first five
It ain't nothing like that first time
We got sick of playing both sides
We got sick of playing
We couldn't figure out who was wrong
Look at us now, we're all alone
Up every night writing these songs
Trying to figure out how to move on
And you know it's hard for me to love
And we went through hell to pull the plug
If you're not God, who are you to judge?
Ah, yeah
It ain't nothing like that first five
It ain't nothing like that first time
We got sick of playing both sides
We got sick of playing
It ain't nothing like that first five
It ain't nothing like that first time
We got sick of playing both sides
We got sick of playing
Can you blame me for living in the past, wanting it back, thinking everything we had would last
I can't be the only one who thinks like that
If I meant anything to you, how could you move on so fast
Baby we lost the first fight, maybe it's not the first time
I mean for what it's worth, I'm sick of playing both sides of the game
I can't be the only one who thinks like that